scyther5/iStock through Getty Pictures
Shares of the life and well being insurer Globe Life Inc. () sharply bounced off the intraday lows set in the course of the buying and selling session after being focused by a brief report printed by Fuzzy Panda. Criticism raised by the SECopenintroduced
Firm Overview:
Globe Life Inc. is an insurance coverage holding firm based mostly in McKinney, Texas that focuses on promoting primary life insurance coverage and supplemental well being merchandise to low- and moderate-income folks.
Historic inventory worth efficiency
It should be, and till just lately was, a really boring firm – until, after all, you have been an investor. Over the previous 15 years, Globe Life has gained a staggering 1,750 % from a post-2008 monetary disaster low of $7.18 per share (March 2009) to an all-time excessive of $132.00 per share in February 2024. It is extremely steady. there was just one break within the run: a 49% month-to-month drop to $56.74 per share in the course of the March 2020 pandemic sell-off, for very apparent causes. Much more constant than the inventory’s rise was income progress, which rose yearly from $3.1 billion ($2.6 billion in premium revenue) in fiscal 2009 to $5.4 billion ($4.5 billion) in 23 fiscal yr. Earnings fared even higher, rising from $2.17 per share (GAAP) in fiscal 2009 — adjusted for 2 3-for-2 inventory splits — to $10.07 per share (GAAP) in fiscal 2023. The agency additionally elevated its quarterly dividend by 286% over the identical interval to $0.24 per share. One might definitely argue {that a} 364% improve in GAAP earnings with a 75% improve in earnings over a 15-year interval just isn’t value 1,738%. Nevertheless, it needs to be saved in thoughts that it was buying and selling with a ahead PE of three.3 firstly of the lengthy rally.
Brief article by Fuzzy Panda
Towards this backdrop, GL shares rallied 53% on April 11, 2024 to shut the session at $49.17 after touching an 11-year low on an intraday foundation – a little bit of a shock contemplating it hit an all-time excessive simply two months earlier than. . The downtrend was in response to a report launched by short-selling agency Fuzzy Panda Analysis that accused the life insurer of fraud and alleged that a few of its brokers engaged in severe sexual misconduct. Insurance coverage Firm Division (AIL). The report consisted of a prolonged file consisting of emails, court docket paperwork, subpoena articles from the US Legal professional’s workplace for the Western District of Pennsylvania and quotes from informants. Globe was accused of being a Ponzi scheme the place recruiting brokers was prioritized over promoting life insurance coverage insurance policies.
Many scams have been reported, together with brokers including protection to current insurance policies to extend premiums (and premiums) with out the policyholder’s consent – by forging signatures and charging bank cards on file.
One other scheme concerned brokers writing insurance policies utilizing the identities of lifeless folks to use a loophole within the agency’s payout construction. Because the bonus for every coverage is paid prematurely and isn’t charged to the agent if he has been energetic for (relying on the scenario) two to 4 months, the agent would merely use his bonus cash to pay the premium for the minimal required interval to keep up his bonus, after which cancel the deceased particular person’s coverage.
There may be additionally a scheme of overcharging and kickbacks the place potential insurance coverage brokers are educated in amenities owned by the executives of AIL’s subsidiary.
Throw in some cool movies of their gross sales reps driving round in sports activities automobiles and appearing like die-hard gangsters, and Fuzzy Panda has achieved the specified impact, most likely making a fortune in gross sales.
Evaluation of the Temporary Report
For the avoidance of doubt, these are severe allegations, and the SEC has since initiated a casual investigation, as has the agency’s Audit Committee. Nevertheless, whereas effectively documented, the report lacks substance when contemplating Globe Life’s backside line. The corporate has been concerned in MLM for many years together with one in every of its primary opponents, Primerica (PMI). One particular person’s MLM is one other’s Ponzi scheme – so nothing new or financially impactful right here. As for brokers beefing up insurance policies on involuntary prospects, it is arduous to think about the observe being systemic, as offended policyholders would have cried out en masse, making it a giant story lengthy earlier than Fuzzy Panda uncovered it. As for the demise insurance coverage insurance policies, whereas this will (theoretically) improve premiums, it hurts (not helps) Globe Life’s backside line. Greater than 80% of AIL’s life insurance coverage premiums come from insurance policies which are in drive for greater than a yr.
As well as, Fuzzy Panda’s chief whistleblower was terminated for trigger for violating the agency’s sexual harassment coverage.
Algebra smart, it is not shocking to see Globe Life rebound 110% from its intraday low on April 11, 2024.
For its half, the agency defended itself the subsequent day towards “self-willed sellers”, saying the allegations have been “deceptive” and that it will “extra totally refute” them “within the close to future”.
Funds and Forecast for 1Q24
Suffice it to say, there have been quite a lot of eyes and ears on the selectors’ convention name accompanying the agency’s 1Q24 monetary report dated April 22, 2024. Globe Life posted (non-GAAP) internet working revenue of $2.78 per share on income of $1.42 billion, versus $2.53 per share (non-GAAP) on income of $1.32 billion in 1Q 23. The quarter met expectations on the highest line and a penny on the underside line. It additionally confirmed a 5% improve in underwriting margin and a ten% improve in internet funding revenue.
For FY24, administration forecast internet working revenue of $11.75 per share, up from an preliminary forecast of $11.55 per share 1 / 4 earlier. Each predictions are based mostly on a collection of midpoints. That enchancment in outlook, together with the agency’s verbal rebuttal of the short-seller report, helped proceed the rally in GL shares, which rose 14% to $75.76 within the subsequent buying and selling session.
Steadiness sheet and analyst commentary:
Aside from the ruckus within the quick report, it was enterprise as standard for Globe Life, which declared a quarterly dividend of $0.24 per share on a present yield of 1.2%. Nevertheless, usually a voracious repurchaser of its personal shares, it purchased again solely 127,748 at a median worth of $122.12 in 1Q24 resulting from an arbitrary shutdown resulting from a possible acquisition. The agency recommended it will actively purchase again shares after the convention name. After repurchasing $15.6M of fairness in 1Q24, it plans to finish the yr with roughly $360M of further treasury shares.
When it comes to rankings, road analysts didn’t react to the temporary report, sustaining a combined stance with 5 purchase or outperform suggestions towards 4 holds. Nevertheless, those that commented after the temporary report noticed their common goal worth drop from $130 to $108. On common they’re to attend Globe Life will earn $11.73 per share (non-GAAP) on income of $5.84 billion in FY24, adopted by $12.86 per share (non-GAAP) on income of $5.9 billion in FY25 monetary yr.
CEO James Darden, CFO Thomas Kalmbach and board member David Rodriguez used the low cost generated within the quick report as a shopping for alternative, collectively buying 4,000 shares after their agency’s monetary report. Every week later, the corporate supervisor added 2,500 shares.
Verdict:
The wager is that Globe Life will take a reputational hit and face some fines if the SEC appears to be like beneath the hood, and sexual harassment allegations needs to be taken very severely, however for any systemic monetary fraud that advantages the agency, which appears extremely unlikely. Sadly, the straightforward cash was made.
GL shares have been already down 21% from their all-time excessive when the temporary was launched after which traded on a ahead PE of 8.93. They now commerce at round seven. Shopping for insiders recommend they do not care, and with extra volatility in choices resulting from Fuzzy Panda, Globe Life is simply too controversial for a giant stake, particularly within the standard insurance coverage sector.
Nevertheless, I’ve created a small “starter” place in GL by indoor problem orders. It is a very small wager that the current controversy will finally die down.