Commercial Metals: Lower steel prices put pressure on net sales (NYSE: CMC )

Funding Thesis: In the intervening time, I price the inventory as a Maintain.

Business metallurgical firm (NYSE: CMC) is finest generally known as the biggest producer of metal fittings in North America and Central Europe additionally manufactures industrial bar, metal fence submit and wire rod. The corporate is a provider of main development tasks on two continents.

Shares are up simply over 11% year-to-date.

The aim of this text is to evaluate whether or not the inventory has the potential for additional upside from right here.

Productiveness

Wanting on the efficiency for the newest quarter (as of June 20, 2024), we see that web gross sales and earnings had been down year-over-year, with web gross sales down 11% over the three months. and divorced earnings per share fell 48% over the identical interval.

Moreover, we see that North America accounts for the biggest portion of the corporate’s web gross sales, and has seen an 8% decline since Might 2023, whereas Europe has seen a 36% decline over the identical interval.

web gross sales over the long run, we will see that in 2024, web gross sales for the February and Might quarters are decrease than the prior 12 months quarter, with the newest quarter nonetheless effectively under the excessive of two.515 billion US {dollars} in Might 2022.

From a stability sheet perspective, we will see that the gearing ratio (calculated as whole present property much less prepayments and different present property much less web inventories to whole present liabilities) has elevated from 2.17 to 2.46 and stays considerably larger for 1 – it exhibits that the corporate has sufficient liquid funds to service its present liabilities.

Click on to enlarge

Supply: Figures (excluding fast ratio) derived from CMC Press Launch: Third Quarter FY2024 Outcomes. Fast price issue calculated by the writer.

From a long-term perspective, we see that the ratio of long-term debt to whole property has remained nearly unchanged over the identical interval.

Click on to enlarge

Supply: Figures (excluding ratio) derived from CMC Press Launch: Third Quarter FY2024 Outcomes. The ratio of long-term debt to whole property calculated by the writer.

On a holistic foundation, we noticed that whereas web gross sales got here beneath stress this quarter, the corporate’s stability sheet continued to be wholesome.

That being stated, it is also value noting that whereas we have seen the share value rise over the previous 12 months, it may be affected by share buybacks, most just lately with $47.94 million in share buybacks in February. Additionally, with rates of interest remaining at 5.50% and the Federal Reserve just lately holding charges at present ranges to cut back inflation, share repurchase exercise might sluggish any more as a result of larger curiosity expense and we we will see a extra average rise in share costs because of this.

Wanting forward and taking dangers

As for Business Metals Firm’s future development prospects, it’ll rely considerably on the trajectory of metal costs and general market dynamics.

For instance, metal costs in the US proceed to expertise downward stress as a result of elevated imports from Vietnam, which have put stress on home costs. Particularly, the typical month-to-month quantity of flat-rolled imports from Vietnam within the first 5 months of 2024 elevated by 453% in comparison with the identical interval in 2023.

Furthermore, it has raised issues that Vietnam is getting used as a dumping floor for Chinese language metal, with the fabric’s origins being glossed over to keep away from tariffs on it. If we see this pattern speed up, then that would proceed to place downward stress on metal costs, and the downward stress we have seen on web gross sales within the North American market may proceed.

We noticed steel margins for metal merchandise fall to $538 per ton from $595 within the year-ago quarter, whereas metal merchandise shipped in overseas tons for a similar interval fell from $788 to $764 and the typical promoting value per ton decreased to 891 {dollars}. from $979 within the prior-year quarter.

That stated, one potential space of ​​development for the corporate to counter the results of decrease metal costs is the rise in infrastructure exercise that’s driving development demand throughout North America this summer season, which can also be taking place in Europe, the place we’re seeing declines. inflation and elevated financial development in key markets corresponding to Poland, which additionally drives demand for development.

Business Metals experiences that there’s nonetheless a major scarcity of housing items within the housing markets, and as such the corporate is effectively positioned to extend gross sales quantity to counter decrease costs within the quick to medium time period.

By way of valuation, we see the corporate’s ahead P/E ratio buying and selling close to a five-year excessive, whereas earnings per share (on a normalized diluted foundation) have been declining since early 2023.

We will see that Business Metals Firm’s ahead P/E ratio is throughout the vary of friends Metal Dynamics Inc ( STLD ) and Nucor Corp ( NUE ).

With the above in thoughts, I consider the inventory is presently pretty valued and earnings ought to improve to justify additional development.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Business Metals Firm noticed an enchancment in web gross sales in comparison with the earlier quarter, however web gross sales and revenue figures had been down year-over-year. I consider that whereas the inventory has the potential for longer-term development, it’ll rely considerably on the extent to which metal costs start to rise once more. In the intervening time, I price the inventory as a Maintain.